| For better
or for worse, rock and roll has been flooded by testosterone since
the time of its conception. Men built this ship, and men sail it.
In light of this patriarchy, it might seem easy to dismiss women
as a footnote to monolithic rock figures like The Beatles, Bob Dylan,
The Ramones, Nirvana, and so many other giants of the past and present.
Even those who do break through are often doomed to be singer-songwriters
or pop divas. Like it or not, men are doing most of the behind-the-scenes
maneuvering. As the editors of Rolling Stone Magazine wrote in October
of 2002, “Rock radio won’t even touch female artists,
while the pop factory keeps churning out sound-alike clones, and
ambitious musicians with something to say find themselves out in
the cold.”
Despite all
of this, women have undoubtedly made some of the most passionate
and powerful music ever written. Female songwriters have penned
songs so eloquent and so poignant that it would be almost impossible
to think of a man writing the same way. Women are vital. They form
a piece of the skeleton of rock music and when they are ignored
the musical universe seems much less complete. Rock and roll needs
women.
Good songs
transcend the barriers of race, class and gender, but we have seen
many moments of transcendence in songs written by women that have
yet to be equaled by the men who have always controlled the game.
Among these unique women are Joni Mitchell, Lucinda Williams, and
Bjork. These three have carved out paths men would fear to tread,
making statements that only women have made – statements that
only these women could have made.
Joni Mitchell
is a genius. As the previously mentioned issue of Rolling Stone
describes, “Joni Mitchell always has been, and always will
be, utterly irreplaceable.” The sound of her voice suggests
poetry, beauty, and clarity. Her words and her winding melodies
are weighed down with sadness and longing but lifted like smoke
by their bittersweet acceptance of beauty. In “A Case of You,”
she sings, “You’re in my blood like holy wine. / You
taste so bitter, and so sweet. / Oh, I would drink a case of you,
darling, / And I would still be on my feet.” These lyrics
drip with emotion and the sound of her inimitable, heavenly soprano
magnifies the meaning of her words immeasurably. I don’t know
who else could sing these songs as well. I don’t think anyone
could. I don’t think anyone ever will again. To imagine Bob
Dylan, Van Morrison, James Taylor, or any other male singer-songwriter
trying to pull it off is ridiculous. They’d fall on their
faces. Mitchell’s songs transcend discussions of men and women
– all good songs should. “Blue,” her landmark
album from 1971, is a plaintive reminder of the beauty that exists
in joy, love and sadness. Along with “Court and Spark”
(1974), which is a bit more upbeat and melodic, “Blue”
is usually considered the pinnacle of her artistic achievements.
However, Mitchell continues to write and record fine music to this
day.
Lucinda Williams
has been recording her fusion of country, pop, rock and folk for
about 20 years. Starting with her 1980 album “Happy Woman
Blues” and onward through 2001’s “Essence,”
every record she has made has been greeted warmly and appreciatively
by rock consumers desperate for music with feeling. Her records
are filled with yearning for the past, hope for the future, restlessness
in the present and a reminder of the most unshakeable truths of
the human condition. The songs are quaint and unpretentious. She
doesn’t reach too far to be profound but still she strikes
nerves that very few in music history have struck. Lucinda will
make you cry not only in sadness but in awe of the beauty of this
“Sweet Old World” (the title of her 1992 masterpiece).
The All Music Guide (http://www.allmusic.com/) calls that album
a “gorgeous, elegiac record” that “expands Williams’
ample talents.” Also brilliant is her Grammy-winning “Car
Wheels on a Gravel Road” (1998).
Bjork, compared
to the other two, is a very modern phenomenon. Her music is laced
with electronic beats, computerized sounds, and unorthodox chord
progressions. She writes simple lyrics that are almost childish
but her words are so rich in imagery and idiosyncrasy that they
come across as strangely profound. With a voice at once like an
ice pick and a soothing massage, she creates music that is wholly
unsettling, entirely original and uncommonly beautiful. Ryan Schreiber
of Pitchforkmedia.com, a respected online music magazine, calls
Bjork “a true genius” who “[takes] music to the
next level.” In my mind, too, Bjork is an artist without peer.
It’s difficult to describe the experience of listening to
“Post” (1995) or “Homogenic” (1997), but
these albums hold together masterfully as focused artistic statements.
In “The Modern Things,” a song from “Post,”
she sings, “All the modern things / Like cars and such / Have
always existed. / They've just been waiting in a mountain / For
the right moment.” So it is with her music. It’s as
if it has been floating in the air, waiting for someone brilliant
enough to make it heard. For anyone who suggests that original rock
music is a thing of the past, listen to what Bjork has to say about
it.
The testosterone-soaked
establishment needs to let these women in, because with their voices
our music is much richer, much more complete and much more human.
For every John Lennon, we need a Joni Mitchell. For every Jackson
Browne, we need a Lucinda Williams. For every Radiohead, we need
a Bjork. Let the women of the past and future be heard.
|